Scabies Treatment Selector
Personalized Scabies Treatment Recommendation
Answer a few questions to get tailored treatment guidance based on your specific situation.
Select your options above and click "Get My Recommendation" to see your personalized treatment plan.
When treating scabies, Elimite (permethrin 5% cream) is a prescription‑only medication that many dermatologists recommend as first‑line therapy. But the market is crowded with other options-some prescription, some over‑the‑counter, and even a few natural remedies. This guide breaks down how Elimite stacks up against its most common rivals, so you can pick the right cure for your skin and lifestyle.
Key Takeaways
- Elimite delivers >95% cure rates after a single 8‑hour application.
- Ivermectin (oral) is useful for crusted scabies or when topical use is impractical.
- Benzyl benzoate and Crotamiton are cheaper OTC choices but may need repeated applications.
- Sulfur ointment is safe for infants but works slower and can be messy.
- All treatments require proper hygiene-washing bedding and clothing is essential for lasting success.
How Elimite Works
Elimite’s active ingredient, permethrin is a synthetic pyrethroid that disrupts the nerve cells of the Sarcoptes scabiei mite. When applied to clean, dry skin, it penetrates the exoskeleton, paralyses the mite, and stops it from laying eggs. Because it targets the mite’s nervous system, human skin tolerates it well-side effects are usually limited to mild itching or redness.
Major Alternative Scabies Treatments
Below are the most frequently used alternatives, grouped by prescription status and formulation.
- Ivermectin - an oral antiparasitic that interferes with neurotransmission in the mite.
- Benzyl benzoate - a topical oil‑based solution often sold as an OTC cream or lotion.
- Crotamiton - a cream that both kills mites and soothes itching.
- Sulfur ointment - a traditional, low‑cost paste used for infants and pregnant women.
- Lindane - an old‑school neurotoxin now limited to severe cases because of neurotoxicity concerns.
- Tea tree oil - a natural essential oil with documented acaricidal activity, favored by some for its fragrance.
Side‑by‑Side Comparison
| Product | Formulation | Typical Dose / Regimen | Clinical Cure Rate | Time to Symptom Relief | Safety Profile | Prescription? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Elimite (permethrin 5%) | Cream | Apply to entire body, leave 8h, repeat in 1week if needed | 95‑98% | 3‑5days | Very low; mild irritation only | Yes |
| Ivermectin (oral) | Tablet 200µg/kg | Single dose; repeat after 7days for crusted cases | 90‑95% | 5‑7days | Generally safe; caution in pregnancy | Yes |
| Benzyl benzoate | Oil‑based lotion (10‑25%) | Apply, wash off after 24h; repeat 2‑3times | 80‑90% | 7‑10days | Can cause burning, especially on broken skin | No |
| Crotamiton | Cream 10% | Apply nightly for 3‑5days | 75‑85% | 7‑14days | Well‑tolerated; may cause mild itching | No |
| Sulfur ointment | Ointment 5‑10% | Apply nightly for 5‑7days | 70‑80% | 10‑14days | Very safe; odor and staining common | No |
| Lindane | Cream 1% | Single 8‑hour application | 85‑90% | 3‑5days | Neurotoxic; restricted use | Yes (limited) |
| Tea tree oil | Essential oil (5‑10% in carrier) | Apply twice daily for 7‑10days | ~60‑70% (variable) | 10‑14days | Generally safe; can cause dermatitis in sensitive skin | No |
Pros and Cons of Each Option
Elimite (permethrin) shines with its high cure rate and short treatment window. Its main drawback is the need for a prescription, which can delay access in some regions.
Ivermectin is a lifesaver for patients who cannot tolerate creams (e.g., infants, those with extensive crusted scabies, or people with skin ulcers). However, oral administration isn’t suitable for pregnant women and requires a medical check‑up.
Benzyl benzoate is cheap and widely available, but the oil can sting and the multiple applications may be inconvenient.
Crotamiton offers both mite‑killing and itch‑relief, yet its slower action means patients must endure itching a bit longer.
Sulfur ointment is the go‑to for babies and nursing mothers because of its safety record, but the strong smell and yellow stains can be off‑putting.
Lindane provides rapid relief but is now rarely prescribed due to its potential to cause seizures and peripheral neuropathy.
Tea tree oil appeals to natural‑product fans, but the evidence is inconsistent and you need a good carrier oil to avoid skin irritation.
Choosing the Right Treatment for You
Think about three practical factors before deciding:
- Severity and type of scabies. Classic itch‑only scabies often responds well to a single Elimite application. Crusted scabies or cases with extensive lesions may need oral ivermectin in addition to topical therapy.
- Age and health status. Infants < 2months, pregnant women, and patients with severe liver disease should avoid permethrin and lindane; sulfur or topical ivermectin (where available) become better choices.
- Access and cost. Prescription barriers push some users toward OTC benzyl benzoate or crotamiton. When budget is tight, sulfur ointment remains effective despite its slower timeline.
After picking a medication, remember that scabies eradication also hinges on environmental control: wash all bedding, towels, and clothing at 60°C (or seal in plastic bags for a week). Skipping this step often leads to reinfestation, no matter which cream you use.
Practical Tips & Common Pitfalls
- Apply to every skin surface. Even areas that look unaffected (between fingers, under nails, genitalia) need coverage.
- Leave the product on for the full recommended time. Rinsing early reduces efficacy, especially for permethrin and benzyl benzoate.
- Don’t share medications. Scabies is contagious; each person needs their own dose.
- Watch for allergic reactions. If you develop severe redness, swelling, or blistering, stop the treatment and seek medical advice.
- Follow up. If itching persists beyond 2weeks after treatment, a second course or an alternative drug may be required.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use Elimite on infants under 2 months?
No. Permethrin‑based products are not approved for infants younger than 2months because their skin absorbs more of the medication. For newborns, sulfur ointment or a pediatric‑tested ivermectin regimen is safer.
Do I need a prescription for benzyl benzoate?
No. Benzyl benzoate is sold over the counter in most pharmacies. It’s a cost‑effective option, but you must be prepared for the potential burning sensation on sensitive skin.
Is a single dose of ivermectin enough?
For uncomplicated scabies, a single weight‑based dose often works, but many clinicians prescribe a second dose one week later to ensure any newly hatched mites are killed.
How long should I wait before re‑applying Elimite?
If symptoms haven’t cleared after 7days, a repeat application is permissible. However, most patients see full resolution after the first use.
Are there any drug interactions with permethrin?
Permethrin is topical and minimally absorbed, so systemic drug interactions are rare. Caution is advised for patients with severe skin barrier disorders, as absorption could increase.
